NY v Trump: Judge Merchan partially lifts gag order on former president
FOX NewsJul 01
Judge Lifts Parts of Trump Gag Order
Image copyright: Anna Moneymaker/Staff/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Facts
The judge who presided over former US Pres. Donald Trump's Manhattan criminal case lifted portions of a gag order Tuesday, permitting the presumptive Republican presidential nominee to criticize witnesses and others involved in his trial.
Judge Juan Merchan, who issued the gag order in March over claims Trump had made "threatening, inflammatory [and] denigrating" comments, kept in place a gag order on Trump speaking about prosecutors and family members of the judge until Trump is sentenced July 11.
The Spin
Pro-Trump narrative
Although this is a partial victory for Trump, it's indeed a victory — especially ahead of the presidential debate, where he has to be allowed to defend himself against questions about his convictions. His First Amendment rights are still being violated as parts of the gag order remain in place, but at least he can go on the offensive when necessary.
Anti-Trump narrative
Although everyone knew the complete gag order couldn't last forever, one has to worry that this might not be the best time to loosen Trump's restrictions. The connection between Trump's words and his followers' violence is well-documented, and keeping in mind the light punishment he has received for violating the gag order in the past; this could turn ugly.