Ocasio-Cortez Moves to Impeach Justices Thomas, Alito

Ocasio-Cortez Moves to Impeach Justices Thomas, Alito
Image copyright: Jemal Countess/Stringer/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • US Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), known as AOC, introduced articles of impeachment against Supreme Court (SCOTUS) Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito on Wednesday, alleging they failed to disclose gifts from benefactors and recuse themselves from certain cases.

  • In a statement, AOC alleged that an "unchecked corruption crisis" on SCOTUS has "spiraled into a Constitutional crisis," arguing that the justices' failure to disclose lavish gifts is "explicitly against the law."


The Spin

Democratic narrative

Thomas and Alito's acts of corruption and expression of their biases have been well-documented, and regardless of other happenings along the US political landscape, the public must pay attention to their lack of ethics. Even if these articles go nowhere, their filing — and actions taken by other lawmakers — prove Democrats are serious about holding justices on the nation's highest court accountable.

Republican narrative

AOC is drumming up bogus accusations in the hopes of kicking constitutional conservatives off the court and replacing them with left-wing activist judges. Thomas is being targeted because he went on vacation with a wealthy friend and his wife happens to work in politics, and Alito because his wife flew a conservative flag outside their house. Neither of these things is unethical, but that doesn't matter to the left in their pursuit of changing the court forever.


Metaculus Prediction


Public figures in this story


Articles on this story

Sign up to our daily newsletter